Wednesday, November 10, 2004
Trading One Bad Apple For Another?
Well ok, last night I celebrated the fact that good old Johnny Ashcroft had resigned. And you know I thought about the fact that shrub may appoint someone just as bad as Johnny. Well folks, enter Alberto Gonzales. Ok I don't know much about him yet. But let's take a look.
First stop, AP story.
Bush Names Gonzales to Succeed Ashcroft
The Left Coaster: What About Bush's Moral Values In Nominating Gonzales For AG?
First stop, AP story.
Bush Names Gonzales to Succeed Ashcroft
"Gonzales drew criticism after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks when he wrote a memo in which Bush claimed the right to waive anti-torture law and international treaties providing protections to prisoners of war. That position drew fire from human rights groups, who said it helped lead to the type of abuses uncovered in the Abu Ghraib prison scandal.Ok I know, those prisoners are ALL obviously guilty, and deserve what they get, because we could never be.... oh my! .... wrong
Specifically, Gonzales' memo said the Geneva Convention that had long governed the treatment of prisoners did not apply to al-Qaida or the war in Afghanistan. The memo called some of the Geneva Convention's provisions 'quaint.'
Gonzales also defended the administration's policy - essentially repudiated by the Supreme Court and now being fought out in lower courts - of detaining certain terrorism suspects for extended periods without access to lawyers or courts."
"'Alberto Gonzales role in the development of policies that ultimately led to the Abu Ghraib prison scandals in Iraq is deeply troubling,' said Ralph Neas, president of the liberal People for the American Way. He said senators should question Gonzales closely on these matters."Next, lets take a look at the left coaster:
The Left Coaster: What About Bush's Moral Values In Nominating Gonzales For AG?
"They (the Administration) began with the plausible argument that the Geneva Conventions were anachronistic in an age of asymmetrical, non-state warfare. Al Qaeda didn't wear uniforms or fight according to the laws of war, they reasoned, and so they were not necessarily entitled to the conventions' protections. But the lawyers - including White House counsel Alberto Gonzales, Defense Department general counsel William Haynes II, Vice President Cheney's counsel David Addington, and Jay Bybee of the Justice Department (who now sits on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals) - went further. They advised the president to sign a blanket statement of policy that the men captured in Afghanistan would not be subject to the Geneva Conventions, and that by executive fiat, they would all be declared 'unlawful enemy combatants,' a category that does not exist in international law. White House, Justice Department and Pentagon lawyers also pushed President Bush to sign a secret finding on Feb. 7, 2002, that would have far-reaching consequences for the nation and the world. 'I... determine that none of the provisions of Geneva apply to our conflict with al Qaeda in Afghanistan or elsewhere throughout the world,' this document determined, adding that the White House also had 'the authority under the Constitution to suspend Geneva as between the United States and Afghanistan, but I decline to exercise that authority at this time.' For all intents and purposes, these memoranda gutted the Geneva Conventions."Oh and also,
"It also doesn't help Bush's cause that Gonzales was counsel for Enron as well."So anyways, I have some serious questions about how much better off we would be with Gonzales as our new Attorney General.
posted by digitaljay @ 8:47 PM MST